National Family Caregivers Association NFCA
Monday Sep 6, 2010 Contact Us Site Map Home National Family Caregivers Association
About NFCA
Who are Family caregivers?
Caregiving Resources
Connecting Caregivers
National Family Caregivers Month
Improving Caregiving
Network - CCAN
NFCA Store
Media Room
New Initiatives
Donate/Join NFCA
Corporate Partners
National Family Caregivers Association
About NFCA
Caregiver Community Action Network The Caregiver Story Project Events Calendar
Family Caregiver Forum

The Family Caregiver Forum

Brought to you by NFCA's Founding Corporate Partner

Welcome to the NFCA's Family Caregiver Forum - a place where all family caregivers can post questions, receive support and communicate with others.



Navigation:


FORUMS > Getting Doctors to Take Notice < refresh >
Topic Title: OFFICE STAFF & MEDICARE
Created On Friday June 18, 2010 5:31 PM
Topic View:

View thread in raw text format


colette

Posts: 360
Joined: Jul 2009

Friday June 18, 2010 5:31 PM
User is offline View users profile

Several weeks ago the GI doctor said it was time for my sister-in-law (SIL) to schedule another colonoscopy. She has personal & familial colon problem history. I hold medical power of attorney (MPoA) and thought I filled out all forms necessary at that visit.

Yesterday I did not feel well and asked Hubby, her brother, to take his sis to the procedure and bring her home. Later when I looked at the results, I also found a form SIL had signed regarding the fees; Medicare may not pay for the procedure; SIL accepts all responsibility for the cost if Medicare does not pay. When I asked SIL what the information on the form was, she said she did not know. The nurse told her to sign the paper and date it. (This would have been w/n 40 minutes of the scheduled procedure.)

SIL has a MPoA to sign forms on her behalf, and a representative payee to handle her finances. How does one get the message over to the office and staff that SIL's signature alone is not valid? All suggestions welcome.



-------------------------
Family Caregivers are not paid because they are worthless; Family Caregivers are PRICELESS!
(paraphrased & source unknown)
 
Reply
   
Quote
   
Top
   
Bottom
     



rzxq2y

Posts: 1603
Joined: Jun 2009

Friday June 18, 2010 5:46 PM
User is offline View users profile

Hi, Colette,

Nice to hear from you again. If I understand correctly, the medical power of attorney is in effect only if she is not in sound mind. Yes, I know that the soundness of her mind is questionable, but the hospital staff mightr not be able to tell, especially theu typically just ask the patient to fill the forms and sign.

Medicare does have limitations on when to pay for a colonoscopy. But if she has not had one done for quite some time and she has personal and family history, I would guess that the fee will be covered.

Best Regards,

Min-Shih
 
Reply
   
Quote
   
Top
   
Bottom
     



colette

Posts: 360
Joined: Jul 2009

Friday June 18, 2010 6:14 PM
User is offline View users profile

Min-Shih,

How do you feel about the ethical part of presenting this form within 40 minutes of the procedure to SIL? SIL was told her signature was needed and complied. She cannot tell me what she agreed to. (???)

Colette



-------------------------
Family Caregivers are not paid because they are worthless; Family Caregivers are PRICELESS!
(paraphrased & source unknown)

Edited: Friday June 18, 2010 at 6:16 PM by colette
 
Reply
   
Quote
   
Top
   
Bottom
     



rzxq2y

Posts: 1603
Joined: Jun 2009

Friday June 18, 2010 8:10 PM
User is offline View users profile

Hi, Colette,

I certainly have problems with the practice. I also have problems with many places do not try to obtain insurance authorization prior to procedures that are non-emergency. Last year, I recevived a biull for a whole month of physical therapy for my wife. When I saw the bill, I was not sure whether we have exceeded the insurance limit, or whether the hospital forgot to bill the insurance. After kmany phone calls with the help of a very nice lady at the physical therapy office, it turned out to be the latter.

So we need to be careful. In your case, Les should have checked what his sister is signhing.

Best Reards,

Min-Shih
 
Reply
   
Quote
   
Top
   
Bottom
     



colette

Posts: 360
Joined: Jul 2009

Friday June 18, 2010 11:17 PM
User is offline View users profile

Min-shih,

I agree Les should have taken a more active role to see what his sister was being asked to sign. If he had a question, the procedure could have been postponed until there was clarification from Medicare as to how much it would pay. I think Les is still in denial that his sister has a problem, and I wonder if he will "pull out" of placing her in an assisted living program.

In looking at the paperwork SIL signed, it seems this group of doctors is trying to eliminate patients on government programs. The paper says the group MIGHT help with a secondary insurance, "but Medicare does not force (the group) to (do so)."

Monday I plan to meet with the business office manager to iron out this issue.

Take Care,
Colette

P.S. SIL did not have to fill out any forms. The nurse presented her with a paper (filled in) and told SIL to sign and date the bottom. SIL did not ask any questions as to what she was signing, according to SIL.

-------------------------
Family Caregivers are not paid because they are worthless; Family Caregivers are PRICELESS!
(paraphrased & source unknown)

Edited: Friday June 18, 2010 at 11:20 PM by colette
 
Reply
   
Quote
   
Top
   
Bottom
     



JudyNFCA

Posts: 46
Joined: Nov 2009

Monday June 21, 2010 10:43 AM
User is offline

I suggest for a start that you find out from the doctor who ordered the colonoscopy what diagnosis was given as the reason for the test. Then check with Medicare as to when they will cover the procedure. And let us know how your meeting with the business manager goes!

Note - My main reason for posting this is because there was a big spam attack over the weekend and at first glance it looks as if the whole Forum had been swallowed by a big, scaly spam monster. Unfortunately, on this system, even when I remove the posts, they stay on the main page list if they were the last post made. The good news is that we are re-doing our website within the next year - and hopefully much sooner - which we hope will make everything run more smoothly. Thank you all for your patience!
 
Reply
   
Quote
   
Top
   
Bottom
     



colette

Posts: 360
Joined: Jul 2009

Tuesday June 29, 2010 12:27 AM
User is offline View users profile

The business manager (mgr) is a caregiver, also. She said she could empathize with my situation.

Although S.I.L.'s papers for medical power of attorney and H.I.P.P.A. were copied by the front office staff at the doctor's meeting in May, the copies were not scanned into her chart. Mgr tried to defend having S.I.L. sign the papers with the reasons: 1) Medicare had to have this paper signed; 2) Staff did not know my S.I.L. personally to know that S.I.L. did not understand what she was signing, and did not have the Medical PoA to refer to.

I explained S.I.L. felt special because she was asked for her signature. If S.I.L. had been asked what the paper stated that she signed, she would not have known. (I realize it is not the staff's duty to make sure patients understand what they are putting their signature to.) If you were to ask S.I.L. today, she would sound as if she knew because she would said state what I told her the paperwork was about.

In our conversation I told mgr had this been private insurance (i.e. Cigna), I would have paid the copay and any deductible when the appt for the colonoscopy was was made. Why was this Medicare form not presented to me when I filled out paperwork at the dr's appt? Had I been with S.I.L. like I normally am for procedures & this form had been presented, the colonoscopy would have been canceled until I learned what (if any) of the bill Medicare covered.

Mgr also clarified "secondary insurance." That refers to private insurance. If Medicare does not cover this, THEN THE BILL WILL AUTOMATICALLY BE SUBMITTED TO MEDICAID which is S.I.L.'s secondary insurance. Mgr went on to say that a routine screening is allowed by Medicare only ONCE EVERY 10 YRS. I suggested she review the patient's history as there is personal and family history of colon problems. Even with a history Mgr states Medicare pays for ONE SCREENING EVERY 24 MOS according to the business manager.

If that is the case, the doctor should not have ordered the procedure, or Ms. Ming should have received a letter to that effect (informed consent) well before the procedure date so that Medicare could have been contacted in advance regarding the billing.

Yes, it was brought up my husband (S.I.L's brother) should have taken a more active role (trying to throw the ball in my court.) Unfortunately I think he is still in denial that sis is incompetent to sign legal & medical papers, and I thought I had signed all the paperwork 2 weeks prior. From here on out, I will be at any procedure for S.I.L.

At this point I am waiting for the MSN from Medicare. I am ready to appeal it if they deny the claim, especially if Medicaid does not pay the claim. I do need to find out what code was used to process the claim for Medicare. At the time of this meeting the billing had not been filed w/Medicare.

Sincerely,
Colette

-------------------------
Family Caregivers are not paid because they are worthless; Family Caregivers are PRICELESS!
(paraphrased & source unknown)

Edited: Tuesday June 29, 2010 at 12:29 AM by colette
 
Reply
   
Quote
   
Top
   
Bottom
     



myonly

Posts: 311
Joined: Apr 2010

Tuesday June 29, 2010 3:55 PM
User is offline View users profile


Dear Colette,

What a royal mess for you to have to untangle!! My first thought, from a medical perspective, regards the informed consent. In our documentation, the doctor has to note in the patient's chart that he/she informed the patient about the risks/benefits of the procedure and that the patient asked appropriate questions. In addition to this, the physician often has the patient voice their understanding of what will happen in the proposed surgery and what the goal of the surgery is. There are big flags on our patient charts in regards to a patient's not being competent to give proper informed consent.

Oftentimes, I'm afraid, folks in medicine are just trying to "get their job done" and get through what they see as formalities. Unfortunately, these oversights can and do have a huge impact on the patient and their course of recovery, as well as their billing status. I'm sorry you have to slog through this.

Gab

 
Reply
   
Quote
   
Top
   
Bottom
     



myonly

Posts: 311
Joined: Apr 2010

Tuesday June 29, 2010 3:58 PM
User is offline View users profile


Also, there is no good reason why her PoA and HIPPA documentation was NOT scanned into the chart! That should have been first and foremost. AND there should have been a flag on the chart regarding the fact that she has a medical PoA. Shame on them!!

 
Reply
   
Quote
   
Top
   
Bottom
     



colette

Posts: 360
Joined: Jul 2009

Tuesday June 29, 2010 6:28 PM
User is offline View users profile

Gabby,

Thanks for the backup from the medical perspective. I am with you on the comment immediately preceding this one. The bns mgr wanted to know WHO made the copies for me so she could "pin it on someone." The girls at the front desks do not wear name tags. IN THE FUTURE, ANY PAPERWORK I TURN IN WILL HAVE AT THE TOP THE FIRST NAME OF THE PERSON WHO ACCEPTED THE PAPERWORK FROM ME.

I think someone realized the Medicare form had not been filled out, and tried to cross the "t's" and dot the "i's" at the last minute. There were 3 options on the form, and the form basically states that you, the patient, have to check the desired option -- not the dr's staff. The financial adviser says SHE highlighted Option #1 for S.I.L. to check, as if to say the highlighting takes the place of checking the option. The copy of the original (given to S.I.L.) does not have any option checked or highlighted.

In my book this doctors' practice will not be paid until Medicare & Medicaid have made their decisions. If I am in the wrong, let me know.

Colette

-------------------------
Family Caregivers are not paid because they are worthless; Family Caregivers are PRICELESS!
(paraphrased & source unknown)
 
Reply
   
Quote
   
Top
   
Bottom
     



colette

Posts: 360
Joined: Jul 2009

Tuesday July 06, 2010 6:28 PM
User is offline View users profile

Gab,

I apologize for the salutation to you in the last post. I will let it stand. I am sometimes know as M&M (Motor Mouth).

Colette
xoxoxo

-------------------------
Family Caregivers are not paid because they are worthless; Family Caregivers are PRICELESS!
(paraphrased & source unknown)
 
Reply
   
Quote
   
Top
   
Bottom
     



myonly

Posts: 311
Joined: Apr 2010

Tuesday July 06, 2010 7:39 PM
User is offline View users profile


Dear Colette,

No harm done - people spell my nickname all different ways, so no big deal. I answer to almost anything. :-)

I'm completely with you on the billing issue. Like you said, make sure you have documented your interaction with that office, who you spoke to and when. I know you are on top of the situation, though. Maybe, too, if the business mgr sees you taking notes when you're speaking with her, it might make some difference in the office protocol. They might actually start to cross THEIR "t's" and dot THEIR "i's"!

Good luck.
Gaby

 
Reply
   
Quote
   
Top
   
Bottom
     

View thread in raw text format
FORUMS > Getting Doctors to Take Notice < refresh >

Navigation:
Top Page Send to a Friend    Feedback

FuseTalk 4.0 © 1999-2003 FuseTalk Inc.
nfca_public_forum ---